How To Fix Brownies With Too Much Oil?

Who doesn’t love a decadent and indulgent brownie? Unfortunately, sometimes we get a little carried away with the oil and end up with brownies that are greasy and unappetizing. But fear not!

There are simple and effective ways to fix brownies with too much oil and bring them back to their gooey, chocolatey glory.

Whether you’re a seasoned baker or a beginner, these tips will help you salvage your brownies and impress your friends and family with your baking skills. So put on your apron, and let’s get started on rescuing those oily brownies!

Why Are My Brownies Too Oily?

Use high-quality chocolate and butter to ensure the best results. It is also possible to make oily brownies by using old chocolate that has been sitting on the shelf for a long time.

Choose a store that has a high turnover of chocolate to ensure you’re buying fresh chocolate. Butter or oil, which have a high-fat content, is another reason. In this case, it will affect the brownie batter to bubble while baking, resulting in oily brownie tops.

What can be done to fix this?

Make sure you use the right amount of butter in your brownie recipe. You will see bubbles in your brownie as a result of the recipe’s high-fat content.

What Happens if I Put Too Much Oil In Brownie Batter?

Knowing the quantity of ingredients is essential to baking. It is obvious that if you double or triple any ingredient, you must also increase the other quantities in the same proportion.

Your brownies will become loose, soft, and oily if you add too much oil, and they won’t hold together after baking.

What Do I Do If I Added Too Much Oil To Brownie?

Don’t worry – it’s not impossible to fix brownies with too much oil. I’ll show you how to identify over-oiled brownies and explain how to reduce the amount of oil in them.

Creating a tasty, moist dessert is as easy as following a few simple steps. Now let’s take a look at how to fix brownies that have too much oil. Check it out.

It is important to pour off excess oil before you attempt to fix brownies with too much oil. Place the excess oil in a separate container after scooping it out with a spoon. As a result, the brownies should have less oil.

Next, the remaining oil needs to be absorbed. Adding dry ingredients such as cocoa powder or flour will do the trick. In addition to helping absorb the oil, these ingredients also contribute to the smooth texture of the brownies.

A few tablespoons of melted butter can also be added to the brownies. By doing this, the brownies will be more texture-pleasing and will be less oily.

How To Fix Too Much Oil In Brownie Batter?

The best way to fix over-oily brownies is to try to manage them and add other dry ingredients. There are a few fixes you can make:

1. The More Flour, The Better

The batter should be mixed with plain flour until it disappears. Excessive oil will be absorbed by extra flour. Add plain flour in small amounts at a time. 

You can test the batter by mixing a teaspoon and seeing if it looks okay now. You may need to add another teaspoon if it does not work. In this way, you will prevent excessive flour from being added to the batter.

2. Cocoa Powder

Cocoa powder is another good option. Mix one teaspoon into the batter and check it. If needed, add more. It is possible to mask the oily texture by adding more cocoa powder to enhance the chocolate flavor.

It is also possible to mix flour and cocoa powder together. By selecting this option, you will enhance the chocolate flavor and absorb excess oil at the same time. Mix 1 tablespoon flour with 1 teaspoon cocoa powder. They should be mixed until they reach a normal consistency.

3. Add Extra Brownie Mix

The more brownie mix you use, the better. Mix it and check the consistency after adding a few teaspoons. You can add more if you need them. 

In cases where too much oil has been added, adding extra brownie mix is a good idea to reduce moisture content and balance the mix.

Alternatively, you can add three to four tablespoons of a packet of brownie mix that you have at home. The mix should become stiff enough to fit into your brownie tray when you mix it through.

4. Cook The Mix For 5-10 Minutes More

Cooking the brownie mix for a little longer will help correct the moisture content after adding more flour, cocoa, or brownie mix.

It will take longer to bake the brownie mix because it has increased in volume. Remove the brownies when the skewer comes out clean when checking the center.

Simply cook it for a little longer in your oven instead of increasing the heat. Cooking the brownies all the way through will ensure they are always a perfect texture.

I prefer baking the brownies for an additional 5-10 minutes in a slightly larger pan due to the increased volume.

5. Bake The Brownies Again After Cutting Them Into Pieces

There is still a chance you can save your brownies if you put too much oil in the oven. You will need to cut the brownies into 1-inch pieces after you take them out of the tray.

Put them back in the oven for 5-10 minutes after laying them out on the tray in small pieces. The edges will be crisped up, and you can make cute little bite-sized brownies.

6. Scoop It Out And Add Ice-Cream

Cooked brownie mix can also be topped with ice cream. The combination of a soft brownie mix and ice cream is delicious. For a cute dessert, layer brownies with ice cream.

7. Air Fry Them

The air-fryer is the perfect way to bake brownies if your oven doesn’t seal properly or you aren’t sure what the exact temperature is. Instead of 35-45 minutes in an oven, they will cook in 15-20 minutes.

The outside of the brownies will become crispy when air fried, and the brownies will stay set even if too much oil is added.

How To Fix Too Much Oil In Baked Brownies?

As discussed earlier in this post, a brownie may be oily for several reasons. If your brownies are really oily, don’t worry; there is many ways to fix them.

What can be done about this?

Cut the brownies into equal pieces after cooling and place them on paper towels to absorb any remaining grease. To prevent your brownies from looking greasy, drizzle them with milk to absorb moisture.

What To Do If There Is Too Much Butter In Brownies?

In the same way that excess oil causes problems, excess butter will do the same. Additionally, the solutions are the same. You can improve the batter by adding more dry ingredients and solve the oil problem by absorbing excess oil in the baked brownies with a paper towel.

What To Do With Too Oily Brownies?

Even if the above tip doesn’t work, don’t throw away your brownies. 

• If the brownie flavor is satisfactory, break them up into small pieces. 
• Add heavy cream, condensed milk, and vanilla to the mixture. 
• Sprinkle the brownie pieces on top. 
• Place the container in the freezer. Let it freeze. 
• A few hours later, enjoy some vanilla ice cream with brownie bits. 

The only way to ensure that your baking project won’t fail is to have a backup plan. Add more Nutella until the brownies taste good, then repeat the recipe. 

Final Words

Here is a quick recap.

Adding old chocolate or too much fat content, such as butter or oil, may make your brownies look oily or greasy.

If your brownie batter is oily, you can adjust it by adding more flour and cocoa powder.

Alternatively, you can fix too much oil in baked brownies if you couldn’t fix it on time. Let the paper towel absorb the excess oil after cutting the brownie into pieces. To avoid the brownies looking greasy, add a few splashes of milk.

You can still use your oily brownies if none of these work for you. Serve ice cream with them after mixing them with other ingredients (such as condensed milk or heavy cream).

Hopefully, this article has answered your question.